Enciclopedia Boulder v1.0

Inicio · Capítulos · 17. Referencias

18.39 17.2.15 Quality gates

ID Gate Severidad
EVID-G01 Every work has exactly one evidence triage profile. Blocker
EVID-G02 No work receives an automatic methodological quality score. Blocker
EVID-G03 All certainty ratings are claim/body-of-evidence scoped. Blocker
EVID-G04 Reporting guidelines are not used as risk-of-bias tools. Blocker
EVID-G05 Framework and version are recorded for every manual appraisal. Blocker
EVID-G06 Not assessed is distinct from low quality. Blocker
EVID-G07 Editorial status is separate from methodological appraisal. Blocker
EVID-G08 Retractions remain resolvable and propagate to affected claims. Blocker
EVID-G09 Every canonical entity has an evidence coverage profile. Blocker
EVID-G10 Single-source and practitioner-only coverage are visible. Major
EVID-G11 Preprints are linked to published versions when available. Major
EVID-G12 Dependency clusters prevent double counting. Blocker
EVID-G13 Contradictory evidence is preserved. Blocker
EVID-G14 Metadata enrichment never overwrites historical aliases. Blocker
EVID-G15 Claims using safety or injury evidence require manual appraisal. Blocker
EVID-G16 Claims about model performance require external-validity review. Major
EVID-G17 Regional language claims include region and date. Major
EVID-G18 Status checks record provider and timestamp. Major
EVID-G19 Maintenance triggers produce an auditable case. Major
EVID-G20 Gap register items have owner, action and status in implementation. Major
EVID-G21 Previous canonical works and aliases remain preserved. Blocker
EVID-G22 All new methodological sources resolve. Blocker
EVID-G23 Statistics reproduce from profiles. Blocker
EVID-G24 The generator is deterministic. Blocker